Do Motor Trade Businesses Need Fleet Insurance?

Fleet insurance is a type of insurance policy that covers multiple vehicles under a single contract, providing a convenient and cost-effective solution for businesses that operate several vehicles. Instead of insuring each vehicle separately, fleet insurance allows all vehicles to be covered under one policy, which can simplify management and reduce administrative burdens. 

This type of insurance is particularly relevant to businesses because it offers greater flexibility, allowing any insured driver to operate any vehicle in the fleet, thus enhancing operational efficiency and reducing downtime due to driver or vehicle-specific restrictions.

What is Fleet Insurance?

Fleet insurance provides comprehensive coverage under a single policy for companies that run a fleet of cars, vans, trucks, buses, or other vehicles. This policy includes various benefits, including third-party liability, fire, theft protection, and coverage for accidents, theft, and damage. Fleet insurance simplifies the administrative process by combining all of a company's vehicles under one policy. It provides advanced features such as telematics and leading claims solutions to enhance fleet management and efficiency.

Like the sights you encounter during your freight hauls, fleet insurance comes in various forms to meet the needs of different commercial fleets.

Since fleets can vary significantly in size and composition, ranging from five small cars to 20 HGVs or different types of construction vehicle, selecting the appropriate insurance coverage for each fleet category is crucial.

Types of Fleet Insurance

To accommodate these variations and provide tailored coverage, insurance companies often offer the following fleet insurance packages:

Haulage and Courier Insurance

Designed for fleets transporting goods and providing courier services.
 
Mini Bus Insurance
Specifically tailored for fleets consisting of minivans or mini buses used for passenger transportation.

Car and Van Insurance

Geared towards fleets comprising cars and vans utilised for various business purposes.

Hazardous Goods Insurance

Designed for fleets transporting hazardous materials or substances.

Public Hire Insurance

Targeted towards fleets operating public-hire vehicles, such as taxis or limousines.

Requirements for Fleet Insurance

To qualify for fleet insurance, businesses typically need to meet specific criteria. Here are the key requirements:

Minimum Number of Vehicles

Traditionally, businesses needed at least five vehicles to qualify for fleet insurance. However, some insurers have reduced this requirement, allowing smaller fleets to qualify.

Vehicle Registration

All vehicles covered under the policy must be registered to the business. This can include various vehicle types, such as cars, vans, trucks, and even hire and courtesy cars.

Driver Eligibility

Most fleet insurance policies cover drivers over a certain age, typically over 18. This flexibility allows any authorised driver within the business to operate the fleet vehicles.

Business Use

The vehicles must be used for business purposes. Personal vehicles or those not primarily used for business activities may not qualify for fleet insurance.

Coverage Type

Businesses must select the appropriate type of coverage based on their needs, such as third-party only, third-party fire and theft, or comprehensive coverage, each offering different levels of protection.

These criteria ensure that the insurance policy is tailored to the business's operational needs and provides adequate coverage for its fleet.

Required Documentation

Alongside the above criteria, there may be documentation that businesses will need to provide, including:

Insurance Documentation

Proof of existing insurance coverages, such as employer's liability insurance and no-claims history, may be required to assess risk and determine premium rates. 

Policy-specific Requirements

Depending on the type of fleet insurance, additional documentation might be required, such as a green card for international coverage in non-EU countries.

Benefits of Fleet Insurance

Fleet insurance offers several significant benefits for businesses, including:

Cost-Effectiveness

Businesses can often secure discounts by insuring multiple vehicles under one policy, leading to substantial cost savings compared to individual vehicle policies.

Simplified Administration

Managing a single fleet insurance policy simplifies the administrative workload, reducing paperwork and making it easier to handle renewals, claims, and policy adjustments.

Flexibility and Customisation

Fleet insurance policies can be tailored to meet a business's specific needs, providing coverage options that suit various types of vehicles and operational requirements.

Enhanced Risk Management

With fleet insurance, businesses can implement comprehensive risk management strategies, including safety programs and telematics, which help reduce accidents and improve overall safety.

Improved Claims Experience

Dealing with one insurer for all vehicles can streamline the claims process, leading to faster resolutions and less disruption to business operations.

Comprehensive Coverage

Fleet insurance typically offers extensive coverage options, protecting against a wide range of risks, including accidents, theft, and damage, ensuring all fleet vehicles are adequately covered.

These benefits make fleet insurance a strategic and practical choice for businesses looking to manage their vehicle insurance efficiently and cost-effectively.

Challenges of Fleet Insurance

While fleet insurance offers many benefits, there are several potential drawbacks that businesses should consider:

Higher Premiums for Certain Risks

Fleet insurance can sometimes result in higher premiums, especially for businesses with a poor claims history or those that employ younger, less experienced drivers. These factors can increase insurers' perceived risk, leading to higher costs.

Coverage Limitations

Fleet insurance policies may have certain exclusions or limitations that might not fully protect all vehicles or situations. For example, some policies might restrict the use of fleet vehicles for personal travel or exclude specific types of coverage, such as certain types of cargo or activities.

Increased Deductibles

Some businesses might opt for higher deductibles to manage premium costs. This means they will have to pay more out-of-pocket expenses in the event of a claim, which can be a financial strain, especially for smaller businesses.

Complexity in Management

Although fleet insurance simplifies administration by consolidating policies, managing a large fleet under a single policy can still be complex. This includes keeping track of coverage details, ensuring compliance with policy requirements, and managing claims effectively.

These drawbacks highlight the importance of carefully assessing fleet insurance options and considering both the benefits and potential challenges.

Managing Fleet Insurance Challenges

To mitigate the challenges of fleet insurance, such as higher premiums for risk, businesses can implement several strategies, including:

Regular Assessments and Maintenance

Conduct regular vehicle assessments and maintenance checks to ensure all vehicles are in good condition. This helps reduce the risk of accidents and breakdowns, which can lower insurance premiums.

Enforce Safe Driving Standards

Establish and enforce minimum driving standards for all employees. Providing driver training and monitoring driving behaviours can reduce the number of claims and improve your fleet’s risk profile, potentially lowering insurance costs.

Use Telematics and Vehicle Trackers

Installing telematics and vehicle tracking systems can provide real-time data on vehicle usage and driver behaviour. This data can be used to promote safer driving and improve fleet management, which can lead to reduced insurance premiums.

Adjust Coverage Levels and Deductibles

Review and adjust coverage levels and deductibles to balance adequate protection and affordable premiums. Increasing deductibles can reduce premium costs and ensure that the business can cover the higher out-of-pocket expenses if needed.

Monitor Driver Histories

Monitor driver histories and target those with poor driving records. Implementing corrective measures or restricting their access to fleet vehicles can prevent high-risk drivers from increasing insurance costs.

By adopting these practices, businesses can manage the potential drawbacks of fleet insurance more effectively and maintain a cost-efficient insurance policy.

Comparing Fleet Insurance and Motor Trade Insurance - What is the Difference?

Fleet Insurance is designed for businesses that own and operate multiple vehicles. This type of insurance covers a range of vehicles under a single policy, simplifying management and often reducing costs. Fleet insurance typically covers a variety of vehicle types. It offers flexibility regarding driver coverage, making it ideal for businesses with a diverse fleet of cars, vans, trucks, or other vehicles used for business purposes.

On the other hand, motor trade insurance is specifically tailored for businesses involved in the motor trade industry, such as car dealerships, repair shops, and vehicle servicing businesses. It covers vehicles being bought, sold, repaired, or otherwise handled as part of the trade. Motor trade insurance can include road risk policies, which cover vehicles driven on public roads and combined policies that provide broader coverage, including premises, stock, and equipment.

The key differences between fleet and motor trade insurance include:

Purpose and Coverage

  • Fleet Insurance: Covers multiple business-owned vehicles used for various business activities.
  • Motor Trade Insurance: Covers vehicles that are part of the business operations in the motor trade, such as sales and repairs

Policy Flexibility

  • Fleet Insurance: More versatile, suitable for a mix of different vehicle types and drivers within a business.
  • Motor Trade Insurance: Often includes specific coverages like road risks and combined policies to address the unique needs of the motor trade.

Target Businesses

  • Fleet Insurance: Ideal for businesses with a large number of company vehicles used for transportation, delivery, or other services.
  • Motor Trade Insurance: Essential for businesses involved in the buying, selling, or repairing of vehicles as a core business activity

Why Motor Trade Insurance is Generally Adequate for Motor Traders

A motor trade insurance policy meets the unique needs of businesses in the motor industry, such as mechanics and auto traders, and provides comprehensive coverage. A comprehensive policy includes several key features to ensure thorough coverage. It provides protection against accidents and third-party liabilities when driving multiple vehicles for testing, delivery, or transportation purposes. 

Combined policies are ideal for businesses with specific premises, as they cover premises, tools, equipment, and stock against theft, damage, and other risks.

Comprehensive motor trade insurance also includes public liability and employers' liability policies, which protect employees and third parties against claims for injuries and damages. These policies are essential in high-risk industries like automotive repair and trading. Product liability coverage is crucial for auto traders and mechanics and offers protection against claims for defective parts or workmanship. 

Motor trade insurance's flexibility allows it to be tailored to full-time and part-time traders. It covers various business activities, from vehicle sales to repairs and maintenance. As a result, mechanics and auto traders are protected against various risks, allowing them to conduct their businesses confidently.

When Might Fleet Insurance Be Necessary?

Fleet insurance can be more beneficial than motor trade insurance in several exceptional scenarios:

Businesses with Diverse Vehicle Types

If a company operates a variety of vehicle types, such as cars, vans, trucks, and speciality vehicles, fleet insurance offers a more versatile coverage option. Fleet insurance policies are designed to cover multiple types of vehicles under a single policy, which simplifies management and often results in cost savings.
Operational Focus on Transportation

Fleet insurance is more appropriate for businesses primarily focused on transportation, delivery, or logistics rather than buying, selling, or repairing vehicles. This type of insurance covers the risks associated with vehicles' daily operation and movement, providing tailored coverage for transportation businesses that motor trade insurance may not adequately address.

Large Number of Vehicles

Businesses that manage a large number of vehicles, particularly those with more than a dozen vehicles, benefit from fleet insurance due to the economies of scale. Fleet insurance policies are structured to handle large fleets efficiently, offering streamlined administration and potentially lower per-vehicle premiums than multiple individual motor trade policies.


Businesses that buy, sell, and repair vehicles primarily will find motor trade insurance adequate and exceptionally well-suited to their needs. Motor trade insurance is specifically designed to cover the industry's unique risks and requirements, providing comprehensive coverage that standard fleet insurance cannot offer. 

The flexibility and convenience of motor trade insurance are unmatched. It can cover any driver with any vehicle, even those only used once. In addition, it protects business premises, tools, and stock against liability and damages. 

Despite fleet insurance's advantages for businesses focused on transportation and logistics, motor trade insurance remains the best option for businesses in the motor trade, ensuring comprehensive coverage for all aspects of their operations.

 

Other news

While premiums for convicted drivers may be higher, due to increased risk, this guide provides more information on how we can support convicted drivers in operating safely and legally in the motor trade.

Explore our essential guide to attaining business insurance for your electric vehicle, including benefits, how to choose and what happens if someone trips over your charging cable.